Product Design & Development
 Share
RSS Feed 

At Issue

Serena, You’re Hired

 Permanent link

David Mantey, Editor, PD&DSomeone is fired up about her job, the meek and mild rally against her. I’m shocked. Gasp.

By David Mantey, Editor, PD&D

“Hey, Old Man River, zip it or I’ll break your hip.” – Sonny Koufax, Big Daddy

I realize that I lead a fairly unorthodox twentysomething life, but I never thought that I’d find myself in a heated debate with a fellow bar patron over how Serena Williams’ latest outburst translated to justified dedication in the workplace. And to quash premature speculation, the Packers were still in the first quarter of a 21-15 come-from-behind victory over Chicago. Bears fans, recognize.

Everyone was up in arms. How dare Serena? (As if amateur tennis fans around the world were suddenly on a first name basis with the star). Where does she get off? That’s not passion, that’s immaturity and has no place on the tennis court. After a line of serious questioning (one question), I found out that everyone in the argument didn’t even watch the match.

I found even more hilarity in the fact that they hadn’t a clue who was even on the other side of the court, or the circumstances surrounding the situation. Apparently, novice tennis aficionados only require a 10-second SportsCenter sound bite to condemn a career.

My fellow debaters’ childlike opinions aside, my point was this: I am passionate about my job. If you tell me I am wrong when I believe I’m right, we will engage in a gentlemanly disagreement. Now, it may not be an obscenity-laced, blood-curdling tirade (depending on the other parties involved and his/her ability to terminate me on the spot), but I’m going to support my decisions and/or stand up against those imposed upon me with which I disagree.

If you catch me on a bad day, I might even combat the decisions I agree with – thus an associate coining the expression, "playing the David’s Advocate." Poor company? Probably, but easier on the ears than ‘devil.’

What happened to the passion in the workplace? The state of the economy seems to have scared too many into tail-tucked passivity. And we’re tucking while paying 2009 prices on a 1997 income according to the U.S. Census Bureau – so I suppose that we’re tucking while collectively bending over. I imagine it winds up looking like something similar to the fetal position.

I understand the demand to work harder/longer, I just don’t know how so many are doing it without passion, without fire. We’re not even smoldering if we’re out to condemn the most public spectacle of workplace passion. I’ll choose to maneuver around other more political examples, because in my experience most people don’t even rely on the sound bite; their opinions are fear-based and older than their mothballed letterman’s jacket. When did people stop reading? I digress …

This was a part of Serena’s first statement, one that had to be amended when her handlers/agent/publicist probably feared that her fans would stop buying double-stuffed Oreos after they witnessed the tragic slaying of a high-priced tennis racquet and were forced to Mad Lib the words hidden behind that horrifying BLEEP. 

“Last night everyone could truly see the passion I have for my job. Now that I have had time to gain my composure, I can see that while I don't agree with the unfair line call, in the heat of battle I let my passion and emotion get the better of me and as a result handled the situation poorly.”

So it wasn’t a beacon of professionalism, but I’ll take passion over complacency in any job candidate.

Trust that I’m not stoking the fire under the resident company blowhard. We can all finger the one or many who jockey for air time on a conference call – this is typically the same group you find repeating daily affirmations in the bathroom after that first cup of coffee. Not only are they blocking you from the lone urinal, but they’re standing two feet from the mirror and working on the script to a Stuart Smalley update while you’re trying to reach the recycled paper towel. Excuse me sir, yes, you are good enough and smart enough, but the hot air is starting to make my hands clammy.

When did it become wrong to ask why? When did it become wrong to question? When did it become wrong to say, “With all do respect sir, I don’t believe that you could be further from the truth?”


I really enjoyed your perspective on both subjects. I agree that they are linked. My son plays baseball at the college level and I certainly want his passion for the game to stay high. There are also plenty of examples of companies where "Why" is treated as a four letter word and where those in top management demand creative solutions from their subordinates but are unwilling to release any of the decision making authority. Instead they prefer to micro-manage them into subservient submission.
Posted by: Brian Hedges at 9/15/2009 1:24 PM


Hello Brian,

I have seen how a passion in athletics has also directly translated to drive in the workplace. Then again, I’ve also seen it lead to a bit too much brash cockiness. I suppose finding the right mix is difficult to diagnose.

I also hear you about the new four letter word, and I know many others who can relate to a time when they’ve been "micro-managed into subservient submission." To those of you reading this now, stay strong.
Posted by: David Mantey at 9/15/2009 2:45 PM


You are confusing passion and respect! Being a young individual I understand how you are confusing one with the other. Doesn't matter who you are playing its how you play. Where do you draw the line? Spitting? Guns? How about bite your co-workers ear off. We are becomming morally bankrupt. What a great education for our youth-
Posted by: hoser at 9/15/2009 3:36 PM


I don’t think that is true. You can be passionate and respectful all in the same. I think the line is drawn at stern speech, just shy of slipping into a shouting match that goes nowhere. While I’ve never resorted to firearms in a meeting, I have seen spitting, but that was more of a mouth-still-full-of-coffee incident. I haven’t been driven to bite a coworker either – especially with this latest H1N1 thing we have floating around. Too many people in the workplace have kids in school, also known as a hotbed for virus activity. Moral bankruptcy and ruthless determination are two different subjects – both deserving of future criticism, thanks for the future column ideas, I appreciate it.
Posted by: David Mantey at 9/15/2009 4:26 PM


You're missing the whole point David. Serena had every right to object to the lineswoman's call. The replay showed that the call was a bad one. However, Serena had an obligation as a professional tennis player to adhere to the rules and policies of the sanctioning organization. That is: she was obliged to act professionally. Take an analogous situation: Let's just imagine that you wrote an article and asked a colleague to review it. Suppose your colleague questioned an assertion in your article that you knew to be correct. Is it acceptable for you to defend your article by threatening to shove your article down your colleague's throat? You say passionate. I say abusive and unprofessional.
Posted by: Mark@GD at 9/21/2009 4:41 PM


register or log in to comment on this blog!

At Issue

Quit Dragging Your Heels
Carrie Ellis, Editor, Chem.Info
Using Customer Ideas In Product Development
Mike Collins, Author, Saving American Manufacturing

Quick Links

Site Sponsors


Most Viewed

Videos & Webcasts

Save Your Fingers, Spare Your Body 3/11/2010
PSENopt safety light curtains and light barriers can be used for finger, hand and body protection in industrial applications. The muting function on the PSENopt total or partial is integrated directly, as is monitoring of the muting lamps.   Continue
Heineken Beer Robot 3/10/2010
The Heineken Bot was developed at the Autonomous Systems Lab in the Product Design and Engineering department of Middlesex University.   Continue
Energy Startup When Money Is Tight 3/10/2010
Company launches revolutionary light powered by both the sun and the wind. The only way to launch a start-up company with a lot of R&D was to have everyone (33 partners) throw a little bit into the hat.   Continue