Product Design & Development
 Share
RSS Feed 

At Issue

We Regret To Inform You

 Permanent link

Just when I thought it was safe to get in front of my computer, I find out that it’ll kill me – and management knew all along. David Mantey, Editor, PD&D on radioactive Exxon workers

by David Mantey, Editor, PD&D

When I put together a comprehensive daily news resource (fancy talk for the PD&D Design Daily), I have the opportunity to not only cover the latest news in the industry, but I also have a chance to transform into a maniacal news junkie.

I click on provocative headlines to read about the unfixable economy, to listen to analysts bang their chests and make wild predictions in hopes of creating some new conventional wisdom by sparking a little awareness-building fear, and to sift through the PR rabble — it’s a practice similar to listening to white noise for hours with hopes of connecting to voices from the other side (dead people).

I recently had a conversation with a futility analyst who, after crunching the numbers and conferring with his peers, found white noise distillation to be 10 percent less futile than combing the wires and feeds for legitimate news. Stand by for his upcoming 1,000-page report that will be available for purchase at the end of April.  

I used to think that Friday night was the wire punch line filled with puff pieces and features similar to those published in Parade Magazine, and the free tabloids littering the streets after a mighty wind. As I’ve found, that Friday night news black hole is a great place to read the news that, I can only speculate, the publishers hope go overlooked. 

My latest conspiracy theory/empty tirade is the result of another notch in Exxon Mobil’s terrible person belt — singular, because corporations are legally considered people — which I found Friday night as I was exercising my individual right to a quiet weekend.

On Friday, a state district court jury in Gretna, LA decided that Exxon Mobil failed to warn workers that the offshore drilling pipes, which they spent decades (between 1977 and 1992) cleaning, contained radioactive contamination. According to the plaintiffs, they were exposed to high levels of radium in the residue that built up inside the drilling pipes. 

What a fact to neglect. I’m assuming that they were trying to skate on hazard pay — or the fact that “radioactive contamination” in the workplace is similar to … radioactive contamination in the workplace. I’m not sure a work situation could be worse — try and have Mike Rowe bring his Dirty Jobs crew into cancer-causing pipes and see if he’s willing to risk his Ford deal for an episode inside a nuclear cavern.

I can imagine the lawsuit years from now. I’ll receive a notice in the mail to be a part of a group lawsuit against my company when a former associate finds that we cheaped out on new computer monitors to save a buck, and had for years been working on knock-off Dells that were seeping radioactive sludge. Pair that with the hidden Adderall in the coffee and the mood-altering chemicals slowly leaked from the sprinkler system, and we’re on our way to the next-generation’s Erin Brockovich — I’ve always hoped to be significantly put upon enough to inspire a Lifetime movie. This could be the ticket.

Sure, the 16 former employees can now split the $2 million for the increased cancer risk, but can anyone really put a dollar amount on anticipated loss of life? Possibly a sliding scale based on tumor size and quantity?

As employees, we have the right to believe that our employers have our physical best interests in mind — unless we know going into the job that we’re ridding a house of asbestos or spelunking into radioactive contamination. Of course, we’ll always expect the corporation to deny any wrongdoing.

As Exxon Mobil’s attorney Charles Gay stated, “We still believe that our pipe did not cause any harm.” Thanks for caring Chuck, it may take some time, but here’s to hoping you lose sleep if the effects of the radioactive contamination ever show in any of the 16 workers. Meanwhile, many of us will skip deniability and pray that it never does.

What are your thoughts? Should employees expect a minimal standard of safety? Comment below or email rebuttals, legal threats and further deniability to david.mantey@advantagemedia.com.


If corporations are legal persons, why can't they be tried for murder when they kill? You can't have it both ways! Or, can you?
Posted by: das at 3/8/2010 2:56 PM


Where I work safety is our culture in fact when we talk about the most important aspects of what we do we say "Safety, Quality, Output" In that order. Without this simple mantra we would not be who we are. You should be able to expect to do your job, with the tools necessary to do it well and do it so you go home at night in the same shape you arrived in. I cannot imagine having to think about whether or not your going to contract a cancer because the working conditions of your job were such that you were exposed to radioactivity! Although the cash may help some of them sleep at night I am not sure anyone would say they would prefer money over a healthy life.
Posted by: Landru at 3/8/2010 6:55 PM


Thank goodness you are only talking about death, disease or disfigurement; for a moment there I thought that either PD&D was in trouble or my subscription was in jeopardy.

But this is a serious topic - thank you for giving it an airing.
Posted by: Pedal Power at 3/9/2010 3:46 AM


register or log in to comment on this blog!

At Issue

Risky Business: Funding Medical Device Innovation
Rahul Sathe, Principal Mechanical Engineer, Surgical and Interventional Products, Cambridge Consultants
Extracting Nuggets from the Invention Mine
Tom Tuytschaevers, a member of our Patent Practice Group

Site Sponsors


Most Viewed

Videos & Webcasts

Visualizing Video at the Speed of Light: One Trillion Frames Per Second 2/9/2012
MIT Media Lab researchers have created a new imaging system that can acquire visual data at a rate of one trillion frames per second.   Continue
The Energy Miser Concept Home 2/8/2012
Lower energy bills while making the house more comfortable, quieter, and safer? Who cares when you're demonstrating a completely Apple-based home control and automation system.   Continue
Inside the Audi A7 2/8/2012
When you take a look at the GPS system, you see real-time Google Earth 3D image navigation rather than cartoon-colored maps. It also powers the night vision system which includes a thermal camera to help detect pedestrians.   Continue

Top Stories and Headlines
EVERY DAY!

FREE Email Newsletter